top of page

Let the Voice Breathe: Why "My Heart" Breaks Mine




There's a moment in EH!DE & Different Heaven's "My Heart" that catches me off guard every time. Not because it's bad. Quite the opposite. The voice—her voice—is stunning. It rises like mist at dawn, a breath made music, arching upward with a kind of graceful ache. And just as you think it will crest into something transcendent—blip. A synthetic, robotic glitch shatters the arc.


Not once. Over and over.


Every time it happens, a little part of me crumples. Because what could've been a masterpiece of emotional phrasing is interrupted—again and again—by what feels like an anxious producer poking the track with a neon stick yelling, "Hey! It's EDM! Look! Look!"

This isn’t about hating on EDM. I love electronic music. I love what synths and sidechains and sound design can add to a piece. But what I don't love is when they get in the way of the story a voice is trying to tell. When they clip the wings of a melody that was never meant to be caged.


There’s a TED Talk by Benjamin Zander that I’ve never forgotten—one of those rare moments where someone captures a universal truth in a single metaphor. The lights are low. The room’s full of people who think they know music. Then Benjamin Zander steps up to a piano with this quiet, almost childlike joy. He’s not just talking—he’s inviting.


Benjamin starts with a familiar tale: the kid learning to play.


“Maybe you’ve heard a seven-year-old at the piano,” he says.

He plays a line. Every note has its own little punch.

Plink. Plink. Plink.

“You see, the first time, he was playing with an impulse on every note.”


Then the kid turns eight—he gives an impulse every two notes.

Nine—every four.

Ten—every eight.

And then, at eleven, something magical happens:


“The eleven-year-old? One impulse on the whole phrase.”


Zander plays it again—but this time, you don’t hear a series of notes. You feel one breath—a motion that moves through time like a single ribbon of light.


One impulse.


No restarts. No bumps. Just flow.


And that—right there—is exactly what this song breaks.


And he sits at the piano—and plays Chopin’s Prelude in E Minor. Not with flash. Not with drama. Just with breath.


You don’t even notice the notes.


You feel this invisible thread pulling you across a canyon of emotion—from the first drop of sorrow to the last echo of longing with no break in between.

One arc.

No bobbing.


And I bring that up because this is precisely what “My Heart” gets wrong.


The voice—oh, the voice—is trying to do the exact same thing. She’s not just hitting notes. She’s telling a story in slow motion. You can hear it in the lift of her vowels, the way she stretches a syllable not because she has to, but because she knows you’re feeling it too.


She’s not just singing—She’s bobbing once.


But the production?


The production is over here jumping up and down at every beat like it’s trying to win a dance battle with the melody.Blip. Glitch. Zap. Cut.


Every line is chopped into synthetic fragments like the producers were afraid to let her finish a sentence.


It’s like watching someone climb a mountain in slow, graceful strides—and every five steps, someone throws a flashing neon sign in their face saying “YOU’RE CLIMBING A MOUNTAIN!!”


Bro. We know.


Let. Her. Climb.


This isn’t just about taste. It’s about structure.They broke the arc. They cut the long gesture into stuttering syllables. They took a voice that was trying to become timeless—and made it timestamped.


And here's the kicker: it doesn’t even make the drop hit harder. There's no payoff to the sacrifice. The drop isn't bad, but it doesn't warrant the constant sabotage of the build-up. It's not tension and release—it's tension and interruption.


So why do producers do this?


Sometimes it's just habit. EDM has patterns, templates. Vocal glitching has become part of the language, even when it's not saying anything useful.


Sometimes it's insecurity. A pure vocal feels too vulnerable, too raw. So they dress it up, smudge it, stamp it with effects to make it feel "produced."


Sometimes it's about algorithms. Short attention spans, TikTok clips, and the need to keep every second loud, modulated, compressed, and catchy. But in doing so, we lose something sacred:

The human breath inside the music.
The arc weaves meanings, from gold to blue to purple, all in one thread
The arc weaves meanings, from gold to blue to purple, all in one thread

The tragedy of "My Heart" is that it almost knew. You can feel the song yearning to let her voice carry the weight. And it could have. It didn't need all the bells and zaps. It just needed space.


So to every producer out there:


Let the voice breathe. Let the arc rise. Let the moment ache.


Then, when the synths do come in, let them come as a choir, not a chainsaw.


Because beauty doesn't always need to be glitched. Sometimes, it just needs to be heard.

Comments


© 2022 by Dimension of Thought. Powered and secured by Wix.

bottom of page